Sirius and Minerva

Written by - Sarah Dragonis

Sirius Black, as we all know, passed away and went beyond the veil in the fifth book. I am here to speak out several cries of distress from some Sirius fans. As well as that, I will be later pointing out several flaws in J.K'S brilliant Mcgonagall.It's just a veil. Or is it?

The arch must be a magical portal. If it isn't, why did Sirius' body, ash or remains of some sort not come out the side?Is this the magical portal to the real 'heaven'? Or is it 'hell'? I very much doubt that Sirius would of been as fit and healthy as he always was, as, from my calculations, from the realease year of the fifth book, right back fifty-five years- which would come in correctly with the years Harry has been at Hogwarts so far and the fact that Hagrid had known Lily, James and Sirius in the year he was expelled. Take back another thirteen years, right back to the year Sirius was born. He would of been born in 1935, which means that this year, on some date, he turned 69. He died at that age? It's a reasonable age to die, but that would mean that Minerva Mcgonagall is in her 80's. Four stunners in the chest would of killed her, and Sirius being attacked alot by his dear old cousin and the fact he would of ben seriously weakened by nearly being kissed by the dementors would of probably killed him before he even got near the veil.

Aaah, Minerva Mcgonagall... yet another Hogwarts mystery! She must at least be 20 years older than Sirius if she was to be a teacher that Hogwarts during the years Sirius was there. That would lead to her nearly being ninty. Don't you think that four stunners in the chest to an 89 year old would kill them? I mentioned this earlier, stunners in her chest, but I bring it up again... she was born in 1915 to tie her age in correcty with the fact she taught at Hogwarts when Sirius was there, proving that unless she was magically modified in her DNA system she would be quite weak by now, quite unable to teach and if not killed by the stunners at least in intensive care in the long term wards of St. Mungo's! This, also, would lead to Dumbledore probably being over 100 years old! Despite the fact that I am a huge fan of Sirius, I refuse to belive he will return in the last two books!Minerva Mcgonagall is a wonderful character also, but she has to die sometime soon! She can't, at 89, be able to carry on as normal, with no change in stature, no change in her body, not a single more grey in her hair, or live like a young woman after receiving four stunners in the chest at that age!
Joanne has forgotten these vital items!